Financial Results and Shareholders Meeting (IR)

EQUITA reports first half 2024 results

  • Net Revenues at €41 million, Net Profits at €8 million and Return on Tangible Equity (ROTE) at 25%
  • Good acceleration in 2Q, with growth in Net Revenues and Net Profits, year-on-year (+1% and +19% vs 2Q’23) and with respect to previous quarter (+39% and +65% vs 1Q’24)

 

Milan, September 12th, 2024 -  Andrea Vismara, Chief Executive Officer at EQUITA, commented: “EQUITA’s financial performance during the first six months of 2024 confirms the improving market environment and the strength of our business model. Looking at the second quarter, results were up significantly quarter-on-quarter in terms of Net Revenues (+39% vs 1Q’24) and Net Profits (+65% vs 1Q’24). This has led the Group to report Net Revenues of €41 million, Net Profits above €8 million and 20% net margin in the first half of the year”.

“Expectations for the second part of 2024 and prospects for the future are both positive. Interest rates are expected to normalize, while capital markets should improve as a result of several institutional initiatives promoted at European and domestic level. The recovery in M&A and the re-opening of capital markets, combined with the leadership of our trading floor, the fundraising of new illiquid, proprietary products and the consolidation of 100% of EQUITA Mid Cap Advisory’s net profits will help us to accelerate growth and continue to offer shareholders a rewarding remuneration”.

The Board of Directors of EQUITA Group S.p.A. (the “Company” and, together with its subsidiaries, “EQUITA” or the “Group”) approved the first half consolidated results as of 30 June 2024.

Consolidated Net Revenues

In the first half of 2024, the Group recorded €40.9 million in Consolidated Net Revenues (-5% vs 1H’23) and €36.8 million in Net Revenues linked to clients[1] (-6% vs 1H’23).

Performance was driven by a strong 2Q’24, with €23.7 million in Consolidated Net Revenues, up 39% quarter-on-quarter (+1% year-on-year). This evidence confirms that the market environment is gradually improving, even if it has not yet contributed materially to the growth of all business areas, due to the persisting uncertainty around potential geopolitical risks and expectations regarding the timing of further decrease in interest rates, which had negatively affected the willingness of investors and issuing companies to act in financial and capital markets, especially on mid-small caps.

The Global Markets division – which includes Sales & Trading, Client-Driven Trading & Market Making and Directional Trading – recorded €21.3 million Net Revenues in 1H’24 (€20.7 million in 1H’23, +3%) and €18.3 million Net Revenues linked to clients (€17.6 million in 1H’23, +4%). These positive results were driven by the robust performance recorded in the second quarter, with growth in all segments, leading to an overall increase of 18% in Net Revenues (€11.2 million in 2Q’24 vs €9.5 million in 2Q’23).

EQUITA confirmed its role as leading independent broker in Italy by recording significant market share in 1H’24, in all relevant segments (Euronext Milan: 8.2%; Euronext Growth Milan: 7.5%; bond market: 6.7%; cash equity options: 15.4%).[2] The team was also ranked as #1 broker in the 2024 Institutional Investor – Extel survey for its trading and execution services, and among the top brokers for sales and corporate access services.

Sales & Trading revenues, net of commissions and interest expenses, increased 10%, from €10.3 million in 1H’23 to €11.3 million in 1H’24. Performance was impacted by the good level of investors’ activity on large caps (mainly banks and blue chips), more than offsetting the still weak trading volumes on Italian mid and small caps. Client Driven Trading & Market Making [3] Net Revenues stood at €7.0 million in 1H’24 (€7.3 million in 1H’23, -3%), experiencing a normalization of the above-average volumes on bonds and derivatives recorded in the first part of 2023. Directional Trading contributed to Global Markets’ result with €3.0 million Net Revenues (€3.1 million in 1H’23, -5%). It is noteworthy that the Directional Trading performance included €0.3 million net income in 1H’24 (€0.5 million in 1H’23) associated to a held-to-collect fixed income portfolio, which was built in 2022 to benefit from a significant and temporary correction of the bond market. Between May and July 2024, some of the investments in the portfolio were reimbursed.

The Investment Banking division recorded €15.4 million in Net Revenues (€17.8 million in 1H’23, -13%), with M&A advisory and Debt Capital Markets being the greatest contributors to fees. From a market standpoint, Italy experienced a significant increase in M&A values (€46.5 billion in 1H’24, €18.8 billion in 1H’23, +147%; source: KPMG) driven by the return to market of medium-large deals, but in terms of number of deals, M&A remained almost in line with the previous year (683 deals in 1H’24 vs 691 deals in 1H’23, -1%; source: KPMG), suggesting still soft volumes on smaller transactions, despite the overall positive expectations for the coming months. This trend in Italy was also confirmed by some statistics at the European level, with M&A values up 31% year-on-year but down 14% in terms of volumes (source: Mergermarket). Looking to corporate debt, Debt Capital Market activities in Italy increased, both in terms of number of deals (from 34 in 1H’23 to 39 in 1H’24, +15%) and values (from €21.7 billion in 1H’23 to €23.2 billion in 1H’24, +7%; source: EQUITA on Bondradar data), mainly driven by investment grade issues. On the other side, despite some growth in Equity Capital Market transactions in terms of number of deals and values (from 22 to 30 and from €2.8 billion to €4.9 billion respectively, 1H’23 vs 1H’24), figures were mainly driven by very few large accelerated bookbuilding transactions, some small listings on Euronext Growth Market (8 admissions with a total value of only €73 million) and a still complex underlying market for IPOs on Euronext Milan, with just one transaction closed in 1H’24 (source: EQUITA on Dealogic data).

In addition to the deals already announced in 1Q’24, in 2Q’24 EQUITA completed several high-profile mandates, including some cross-border transactions. The Investment Banking team assisted as financial advisor: Gyrus Capital in the sale of Intellera Consulting to Accenture; Macquarie Asset Management in the sale of Hydro Dolomiti Energia to Gruppo Dolomiti Energia; Newlat Food in the acquisition of the UK group Princes; the shareholders of Ricami NBM in the sale of a minority stake to Gruppo Florence; Ariadne Group in the entry of DGS – portfolio company of H.I.G. Capital – in the company’s share capital. The investment banking team – working closely with the trading floor – also assisted: TIP – Tamburi Investment Partners as placement agent in the issue of €290.5 million of senior unsecured bonds; Alperia as placement agent in the issue of €250 million of senior unsecured green bonds; BFF as joint lead manager in the issue of €300 million of social senior preferred bonds; Banca Popolare di Sondrio as joint lead manager in the issue of €500 million of senior preferred green bonds; Racing Force Group as sole bookrunner in the €8 million rights issue through an accelerated bookbuilding.

In 2Q’24 the Investment Banking division recorded €11.1 million Net Revenues (€11.5 million in 2Q’23, -3%), mainly thanks to the positive contribution of M&A and Debt Capital Market activities, and despite the comparison with a very strong 2Q’23, where the Equity Capital Market’s team acted with senior roles in four IPOs.

In June 2024 the Group announced the addition of John Andrew as senior advisor, bringing the EQUITA advisory platform to a wider and international audience, with a specific focus on M&A advisory for private equity funds.

The Alternative Asset Management division recorded €4.1 million Net Revenues in 1H’24 (€4.4 million in 1H’23, -6%). Assets under management increased to €1,015 million as of 30 June 2024 (€891 million as of 31 December 2023 and €937 million as of 30 June 2023) and proprietary, illiquid products – which benefit from an intrinsic higher profitability – represented 49% of those assets. This exceeded the percentage reported in 1Q’24 thanks to the fundraising of a new illiquid product (in June 2024, the Group announced the first closing of EQUITA Green Impact Fund – EGIF with €100 million commitments) and the completion of four private debt investments. Asset management fees (liquid strategies, private debt, private equity and renewable infrastructures) were down 17% year-on-year (€3.1 million in 1H’24, €3.7 million in 1H’23) due to the comparison with the previous year, which included the equalization fee resulting from the final closing of EQUITA Smart Capital – ELTIF in 2Q’23 and a change in the calculation methodology of management fees on EPD II, from commitment to invested capital. It is worth noting that in 2Q’24, the private debt team completed additional investments and increased the invested capital of EPD II significantly, to which management fees are now applied. The team was also ranked #1 in the “Europe Direct Lender Subordinated” and #2 in the “Southern Europe Direct Lender” and “Italy Direct Lender” rankings (source: Debtwire, 1H’24 LTM).

The Investment Portfolio[4], equal to approximately €18 million as of 30 June 2024 (€16 million as of 31 December 2023 and €10 million as of 30 June 2023), contributed to the results of the Alternative Asset Management division with €1.1 million Net Revenues (€0.7 million in 1H’23). This included a capital gain recorded following the purchase of an additional fund share of EPD (€0.4 million in 1Q’24).

In 2Q’24 the Alternative Asset Management recorded €1.4 million Net Revenues, down year-on-year (€2.5 million, -44%), for the reasons stated above.

It is worth noting that despite the positive results achieved by EQUITA to date and considering the approaching deadline of June 2025, the management of the flexible fund "Euromobiliare Equity Selected Dividend" will be internalized by Euromobiliare Asset Management SGR, in order to restructure the product and change the investment strategy. The other flexible fund managed by EQUITA on behalf of Euromobiliare Asset Management SGR (“Euromobiliare Mid Small Cap”) will continue to be managed by the EQUITA Capital SGR until maturity (December 2024). As of June 30, 2024, the assets under management of the two funds amounted to €188 million.

In parallel to its investing and monitoring activities, the private debt team is working on fundraising its third fund (EPD III), which will qualify as an Article 8 product under the European SFDR, promoting environmental, social and governance best practices in its portfolio companies. The team is seeing a further diversified investor base in terms of both domestic and international LPs, and the aim is to raise at least €200 million by 2024 year-end and close the fund with €300 million commitments in 2025.

The Research Team continued to support all other Group’s businesses, assisting institutional investors with research reports and insights on more than 150 Italian (ca. 96% of the Italian total market capitalization) and foreign listed companies, as well as on debt instruments, strengthening its presence in the fixed income domain. The team was ranked #1 in the 2024 Institutional Investor - Extel survey for its research on small and mid-caps.

Consolidated Profit & Loss (Reclassified)

Personnel Costs[5],[6] decreased from €20.0 million in 1H’23 to €18.9 million in 1H’24 (-6%), in line with the trend in Consolidated Net Revenues. The number of professionals reached 192 as of 30 June 2024 (195 as of 31 December 2023 and 195 as of 30 June 2023). The Normalized Compensation/Revenue ratio was 47.0% (47.1% in 1H’23)[7]. Operating Costs decreased by 6%, down from €11.1 million to €10.4 million. The comparison year-on-year is affected by the inclusion of some non-recurring expenses in 2Q’23 (c. €0.8 million) mainly linked to the Group’s 50th anniversary. Among operating costs, Information Technology expenses increased 5% (€3.2 million in 1H’23, €3.3 million in 1H’24), driven by some variable infoproviding costs deriving from higher post trading activities. Trading fees [8] stood at the same level of 2023 (€1.7 million) thanks to initiatives aimed at improving efficiency on equity trading, in addition to a lower activity from institutional clients on derivatives, despite growing volumes in Sales & Trading and Client-Driven Trading & Market Making. Cost/Income ratio[9] was 71.8% (72.8% in 1H’23, 70.9% excluding non-recurring expenses).

Consolidated Profit Before Taxes was €11.5 million (€11.7 million in 1H’23, -1%) and Consolidated Net Profit was €8.1 million (€8.0 million in 1H’23, +1%). Net margin increased to 20% (19% in 1H’23). Adjusted Consolidated Net Profit – which excludes the post-taxes impact of non-recurring expenses and the long-term incentive plan addressed to Top Management (“LTIP”) – was €8.1 million (€8.7 million in 1H’23, -7%), with an adjusted net margin of 20%, in line with the previous year.

Looking to the second quarter of 2024, Consolidated Net Profit reached €5.1 million, increasing significantly year-on-year (+19% vs 2Q’23) and quarter-on-quarter (+65% vs 1Q’24).

Consolidated Shareholders’ Equity

Consolidated Shareholders’ Equity was €97.6 million as of 30 June 2024. The Average Return on Tangible Equity (ROTE) was 25% and the solid capital position at Group level was confirmed by an IFR ratio of 3.6x (3.7x in 1H’23), well above minimum requirements.[10]

Outlook 2024

For the second half of 2024, the Group expects a further decline in interest rates, a significant progress in some of the initiatives launched at institutional level to foster the development of capital markets, and a resilient performance of all the major economies globally. Management is confident that the market environment will evolve positively for the investment banking industry in Italy, as is gradually happening in other markets. This should lead to an increase in the number of smaller M&A transactions and a gradual re-opening of the equity capital markets, resulting in a significant improvement starting from 2025. EQUITA will also benefit from the positive contribution of the brokerage activities and the increase in management fees deriving from the fundraising of new illiquid, proprietary products such as EPD III and EGIF, which will bring the expected result for the current year in line with shareholder remuneration target.

 

* * *

According to paragraph 2 of Article 154-bis of the Consolidated Finance Law, the Executive appointed to draft corporate accounts, Stefania Milanesi, stated that the accounting information herein included tallies with the company’s documentary evidence, ledgers and accounts.

* * *

 

[1] Excluding Directional Trading activities, the impacts of the Investment Portfolio linked to Alternative Asset Management activities and the performance fees from asset management activities.

[2] Source: AMF Italia. Figures refer to brokered volumes on behalf of third parties.

[3] “Client-Driven Trading & Market Making” and “Directional Trading” are an internal reporting representation of Proprietary Trading

[4] The Investment Portfolio includes the investments made by the Group in the Alternative Asset Management products that have been already launched, such as private debt funds for instance, with the purpose of further aligning EQUITA’s and investors’ interests.

[5] Excludes compensation of Board of Directors and Statutory Auditors. Those items are included in Other operating costs.

[6] Excludes the provisions for the cash-settlement of the long-term incentive plan (“LTIP”).

[7] Excludes incomes attributable to shareholders which do not contribute to the remuneration of the Group’s professionals.

[8] Item directly linked to the Net Revenues of the Global Markets.

[9] Ratio between Total Costs and Consolidated Net Revenues.

[10] IFR ratio is calculated pursuant to EU 2033/19 Regulation. Starting from 2024, the IFR ratio calculation methodology has changed and the previous year ratio has been recalculated accordingly.

Download the press release

1H'24 Results